Author: Belén Gómez Giménez
"It is without question that embryologists work tirelessly to help families achieve their dream of bringing a healthy baby home"
It is estimated that 186 million people in the world have infertility issues. Infertility is defined as the inability to achieve conception by natural means through unprotectected sexual intercouse after one year.
Gynaecologists, andrologists, nurses and psychologists are the professionals who attend to couples from the very beginning. However, there are also other important professionals in fertility centres who work discreetly and with no direct contact with patients, and yet help them in their aspiration to raise a family. They are mainly biologists, but there are also chemists or biotechnologists whose role inside the laboratory is crucial.
The present text intends to explain more accurately who embryologists are, with details on their specific tasks in the laboratory.
WHO ARE THE EMBRYOLOGISTS?
An embryologist is a reproduction biology specialist. In particular, clinical embryologists are in charge of manipulating eggs, sperm and embryos in order to achieve fertilisation. Although most of the decisions related to treatments are often taken by doctors, it is the embryologists' call to decide on several aspects of the appropriate approach for the specific treatment (1), as well as coordinating the performance of every activity in the laboratory. In some countries, embryologists are even responsible for informing patients about certain laboratory procedures and, to some extent, embryo development, too (1). These responsibilities require embryologists to have wide experience in clinics, high degree of technical skills and extensive knowledge of reproductive human biology (2).
TREATMENTS IN ASSISTED REPRODUCTION CLINICS
Couples who decide to go through a fertility treatment are normally asked for blood tests to determine their hormone profile. Men usually go through semen analyses, too, and it is not uncommon for both partners to be subjected to physical examination if required, looking to discard specific abnormalities of the reproductive system. Once gynaecologists and/or andrologists have diagnosed the specific issue, they deliberate along with the senior embryologist on the most appropriate treatment depending on woman age, sperm quality or genetic problems. Broadly speaking, three different approaches can be considered: intrauterine insemination, in vitro fertilization and intracytoplasmatic sperm injection.
Intrauterine insemination (IUI) is probably the easiest and least invasive procedure. It is indicated in very clear and specific cases such as tube obstruction, cervical factor infertility (3) or erectile dysfunction, and even some other unclear fertility issues that result in the inability to conceive by natural means (3). IUI consists in increasing gamete (spermatozoa) density at the site of fertilization by introducing sperm directly into the uterus (4). This technique requires previous sperm capacitation in the laboratory; capacitation is a natural process that comprises several physiological changes in the sperm necessary for fertilisation. Embryologists perform different procedures based on their evaluation of motile sperm that allows for selection of the best gametes (5) [find more about sperm selection in our previous post here].
Couples suffering from low sperm count or low sperm motility on the male side, or damaged Fallopian tubes or endometriosis on the female side (and more complex cases of infertility for either of them) are usually recommended to resort to either in vitro fertilization (IVF) or intracytoplasmatic sperm injection (ICSI) (depending on the particular situation). In both cases, ovarian stimulation is required for women. Hormonal stimulation of the ovary aims to increase the number of oocytes produced during the cycle; these oocytes must reach a minimum size in order to mature and be retrieved for the following procedures (either IVF or ICSI) (6, 7). Collection of oocytes is done through follicular puncture by means of laparoscopic transvaginal surgery. Whereas for IVF the sperm concentration used is similar to natural conditions in order to mimic the natural environment of the oocyte in the Fallopian tubes, cases of severe male factor infertility may require the use of ICSI (8). This procedure consists in the injection of an individual spermatozoon into the mature oocyte, thus being actually fertilised by the embryologist, one by one (9). Sperm selection is based on morphology and motility [learn more about sperm selection through our previous post here].
Twenty-four hours after the procedure, embryologists verify whether fertilisation has occurred by looking for two pronuclei under the microscope. The presence of two pronuclei is the first sign of fertilisation (one from each gamete), and they are to be fused into a single one in a process called syngamy (10)
In some cases, couples with genetic family history attend clinics in order to avoid passing the disease down to their offspring. Such situation requires performing preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). This analysis, usually carried out at day 3 or 5 of embryo development, identifies embryos affected with the genetic disorder (11). Before being transferred, embryos are cultured for 3, 5 or 6 days (depending on a variety of factors and upon the embryologist´s own criterion). Based on PGD results, only healthy embryos will be selected for transfer into the womb. The number of embryos to be transferred is determined by specific regulations in each country, being just one the ideal situation, whereas spare embryos are derived for cryopreservation. Once all the above is done, the extensive work of the embryologist gets to an end.
It is important to highlight that every single procedure is carried out in the laboratory under strict hygienic and sterile conditions. Also, the use of any perfume, deodorant and alike is completely forbidden just to prevent potential volatile organic compounds (VOS) from affecting developing embryos. In the laboratory, the use of caps, masks and the appropriate scrubs is mandatory for embryologists, and embryos are quickly placed in incubators that mimic the natural environment of the uterus (12). As for the timelines, embryologists work in shifts with the purpose of being available twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week. Assisted reproduction treatments must follow a strict timeline given the fact that procedures must be done at an exact time point in order to guarantee their success until transfer day. As a consequence, the work of embryologists is intense and often requires long-hour shifts.
Embryologists are extensively-trained professionals with wide experience in assisted reproduction technologies (ART) (1). To increase their knowledge and technical skills to perform ART-related procedures, they are continually trained in new methodologies and go through continuous education in the field of embryology (2). These highly-qualified professionals are in charge of the routine maintenance of the laboratory and equipment, sperm handling and processing for IUI, IVF and ICSI, cryopreservation of biological material, tissue sampling for biopsies for genetic analyses and PGD, or even embryo culture, among other tasks (2). These also include a strict and exhaustive record of the procedures for safety purposes. It is actually on the embryologists how to evaluate gametes and embryos, and to choose which ones are the most appropriate to be used and which should be kept in case future use is needed.
It is without question that embryologists work tirelessly to help families achieve their dream of bringing a healthy baby home.
1-Medicine ASiR. The Alpha Consensus Meeting on the professional status of the clinical embryologist: proceedings of an expert meeting. Reprod Biomed Online. 2015;30(5):451-61.
2-Go KJ. 'By the work, one knows the workman': the practice and profession of the embryologist and its translation to quality in the embryology laboratory. Reprod Biomed Online. 2015;31(4):449-58.
3-Allen, N. C., Herbert, C. M., Maxson, W. S., Rogers, B. J., Diamond, M. P., & Wentz, A. C. (1985). Intrauterine insemination: A critical review. Fertility and Sterility, 44(5), 569-580.
4-Ombelet W, Van Robays J. Artificial insemination history: hurdles and milestones. Facts Views Vis Obgyn. 2015;7(2):137-43.
5-Fraser LR. Sperm capacitation and the acrosome reaction. Hum Reprod. 1998;13 Suppl 1:9-19.
6-Brinsden PR. Superovulation strategies in assisted conception. In: Brinsden PR. A Textbook of In Vitro Fertilization and Assisted Reproduction: The Bourn Hall Guide to Clinical and Laboratory Practice. Cambridge: Taylor and Francis group; 2005. p. 177-188.
7-Ventura-Juncá P, Irarrázaval I, Rolle AJ, Gutiérrez JI, Moreno RD, Santos MJ. In vitro fertilization (IVF) in mammals: epigenetic and developmental alterations. Scientific and bioethical implications for IVF in humans. Biol Res. 2015;48:68.
8-Eftekhar M, Mohammadian F, Yousefnejad F, Molaei B, Aflatoonian A. Comparison of conventional IVF versus ICSI in non-male factor, normoresponder patients. Iran J Reprod Med. 2012;10(2):131-6.
9-Simopoulou M, Gkoles L, Bakas P, Giannelou P, Kalampokas T, Pantos K, et al. Improving ICSI: A review from the spermatozoon perspective. Syst Biol Reprod Med. 2016;62(6):359-71.
10-Elder K, Dale B. Sperm-oocyte interaction. In: In-Vitro Fertilization. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2011. p. 50-63.
11-Beyer CE, Willats E. Natural selection between day 3 and day 5/6 PGD embryos in couples with reciprocal or Robertsonian translocations. J Assist Reprod Genet. 2017;34(11):1483-92.
12-Agarwal N, Chattopadhyay R, Ghosh S, Bhoumik A, Goswami SK, Chakravarty B. Volatile organic compounds and good laboratory practices in the in vitro fertilization laboratory: the important parameters for successful outcome in extended culture. J Assist Reprod Genet. 2017;34(8):999-100.
Author: María Caballero
"(..) it is important to choose the appropiate fertility preservation procedure according to the treatment".
Once someone is diagnosed with any kind of disease, the first step is to decide the appropriate treatment. In many cases, such treatment can seriously affect the reproductive capacity, and so it is important to consider the option of fertility preservation (FP) when it comes to individuals at reproductive age or prepubertal children (2, 3) (Figure 1).
Although most of the articles about FP are related to oncology patients (4, 5, 6, 7), there are other diseases and situations in which considering FP may be also important. Some of these diseases include autoimmune diseases like systemic lupus erythematosus (8) or genetic conditions that can cause premature ovarian insufficiency in women, such as Turner’s syndrome or fragile X-related mental retardation, or hypogonadism and azoospermia/oligozoospermia in men, like in individuals with Klinefelter’s syndrome (reviewed in 2). Moreover, other circumstances exist in which FP must be considered, such as sex reassignment surgeries (2) or a variety of social reasons that may end up hampering or delaying parenthood to otherwise perfectly fertile couples (9).
Below, currently available procedures for both women and men are addressed, as well as other procedures still at experimental stage.
AVAILABLE FERTILITY PRESERVATION PROCEDURES
Nowadays, two options for FP in males can be found: gonadal shielding and sperm cryopreservation. In cases in which radiotherapy is unavoidable, gonadal shielding may result helpful since it seems to mitigate the effects of radiation, especially in children (10, 11). This procedure consists in covering the testes with a lead block or apron to avoid direct exposure to radiation (10); however, it does not completely prevent from radiation damage. Therefore, the best option for FP in pubertal and adult males is most likely sperm cryopreservation (Figure 1). Even though the sample is usually collected by masturbation, it may be also obtained by other methods including testicular sperm extraction (TESE) or electroejaculation. These methods are commonly applied in cases in which the previous approach is not possible due to specific reasons, such as certain physical/psychological conditions or even religious beliefs (2, 11).
Several options are currently available for FP in female patients, including oocyte and embryo cryopreservation, ovarian transposition or gonadal shielding. These options are more invasive and time-consuming than for the male counterpart, and so it is important to choose the appropriate FP procedure according to the treatment (3).
Oocyte and embryo cryopreservation have been established as standard methods by the American Society of Reproductive Medicine since 2012 (3, 12) (Figure 2). Between these two techniques, oocyte cryopreservation is usually the preferred one (2); even though embryo cryopreservation is offered to women with a partner and shows great results, it may result in issues past some years; for instance, if the couple divorces or the patient does not recover from the disease (12). Both methods require medical ovarian stimulation at the beginning, as well as follicular monitoring and transvaginal oocyte retrieval. The whole process can take around two weeks (3, 11). Sometimes, harvesting of immature oocytes and the subsequent in vitro maturation may be indicated for those patients who cannot undergo controlled ovarian stimulation, like prepubertal girls or women suffering from polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS) (2, 13). Once the oocyte matures, it will be eventually cryopreserved (to learn more about oocyte cryopreservation, read our post on “Social egg freezing”).
In those cases in which oocyte/embryo cryopreservation is not possible due to the urge to commence the treatment, patients may also resort to the other methods. Both gonadal shielding and ovarian transposition are indicated when radiation on the pelvic area is necessary (11, 15). Ovarian transposition requires surgical intervention to remove the ovaries and fix them, usually to the anterolateral abdominal wall. In these cases, it is recommended to collect a biopsy sample of ovarian tissue, since certain risk of failure is expected (12).
EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES AND FUTURE PROSPECTS
The only available method for FP in prepubertal male children so far is gonadal shielding. However, the option of testicular tissue cryopreservation (TTC) is sometimes offered by some clinics, as well. This technique remains experimental and there are currently no reports on reimplantation of testicular tissue or achievement of pregnancy (11). Due to the risk of reintroducing malignant cells (2), TTC still depends on the improvement of other techniques for the maturation of spermatogonial stem cells into mature sperm, which is necessary for current assisted reproduction techniques (IVF and ICSI) (3).
Regarding female FP methods, the experimental ovarian tissue cryopreservation technique is also offered by some clinics, and it is the only option for prepubertal females and for those patients who cannot delay the initiation of the treatment (3). In this technique, part of the ovarian cortex with the primordial follicles is harvested and vitrified (4). Certain studies have demonstrated successful pregnancies in patients with transplanted ovarian tissue (3) (to learn more about ovarian tissue cryopreservation, read our post “Ovarian tissue cryopreservation. Current procedures and outcomes”).
Treatments with gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonists (GnRHa) are a common practise in different situations, including certain cases of infertility or sex hormone-related issues. FP approaches required in cases of chemotherapy treatments may include administration of GnRHa, since they have been proved to be efficient in keeping ovaries quiescent and reducing their regular activity. This means inhibition of the so-called hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis, which is the main hormone pathway regulating ovarian and follicular activity. By administering GnRHa’s, it would be possible to reduce the blood flow to the ovary, thus preserving follicles (4), so that they can grow and mature later on once chemotherapy treatment is over. However, evidence for its efficiency is still relatively low, and so further research is still necessary on this field (4, 16).
Looking into the future, potential prospectives for female FP may include in vitro activation of cryopreserved follicles within the ovarian tissue, in vitro follicle culture and development of an artificial ovary into which primordial follicles could be eventually transplanted and cultured (2).
The use of stem cells has been demonstrated to have promising results in the generation of both male and female artificial gametes (2, 17). Embryonic stem cells (ESCs), induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) and embryonic germ cells (EGCs) are different types of stem cells with distinct degrees of pluripotency; this means they are able to differentiate into any (or almost any) cell type and tissue present in the body (17). In human embryos, primordial germ cells (PGCs) represent the earliest stage of gametes that, after a series of reprogramming changes and differentiation, will result in sperm or oocytes in the adult. Using the above-mentioned pluripotent (or totipotent) cells, several studies have reported it possible to generate germ cells that will eventually differentiate into fully functional sperm and eggs (17).
On the other hand, the use of PGCs present in the gonads of the progenitors, which are spermatogonial stem cells (SSC) in the male and ovarian stem cells (OSC) in the female, have been also studied for artificial gamete generation by in vitro propagation of SSC and by in vitro propagation and re-aggregation of OSC in the ovarian tissue (reviewed in 17).
FP is an essential issue to keep in mind in situations in which the fertility capacity is at stake, which usually happens when undergoing certain medical treatments (or other circumstances).
Currently, there exist several available options for patients and people, both at prepubertal and reproductive age, who need to preserve their fertility. Even though the most used one is gamete cryopreservation, other experimental techniques, such as the ovarian/testicular tissue cryopreservation, should be born in mind. There is still a clear need for improvement of those experimental techniques, since every disease and situation are different, and because the use of gamete cryopreservation is not always a viable option.
1. Jeruss JS, Woodruff TK. Preservation of Fertility in Patients with Cancer. N Engl J Med. 2009;360(9):902-911.
2. Martinez F. Update on fertility preservation from the Barcelona International Society for Fertility Preservation–ESHRE–ASRM 2015 expert meeting: indications, results and future perspectives. Hum Reprod. 2017;32(9):1802-1811.
3. Burns KC, Hoefgen H, Strine A, Dasgupta R. Fertility preservation options in pediatric and adolescent patients with cancer. Cancer 2018.
4. Harada M, Osuga Y. Fertility preservation for female cancer patients. Int J Clin Oncol. 2018.
5. Vakalopoulos I, Dimou P, Anagnostou I, Zeginiadou T. Impact of cancer and cancer treatment on male fertility. Hormones (Athens). 2015;14(4):579-589.
6. Kemertzis MA, Ranjithakumaran H, Hand M, Peate M, Gillam L, McCarthy M, Super L, McQuillan S, Drew S, Jayasinghe Y, Orme L. Fertility Preservation Toolkit: A Clinician Resource to Assist Clinical Discussion and Decision Making in Pediatric and Adolescent Oncology. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol. 2018;40(3):e133-e139.
7. Joshi S, Savani BN, Chow EJ, Gilleece MH, Halter J, Jacobsohn DA, Pidala J, Quinn GP, Cahn JY, Jakubowski AA, Kamani NR, Lazarus HM, Rizzo JD, Schouten HC, Socie G, Stratton P, Sorror ML, Warwick AB, Wingard JR, Loren AW, Majhail NS. Clinical guide to fertility preservation in hematopoietic cell transplant recipients. Bone Marrow Transplant. 2014;49(4):477-484.
8. Choux C, Cavalieri M, Barberet J, Samson M, Bonnotte B, Fauque P, Sagot P. [Immunosuppressive therapy and fertility preservation: Indications and methods]. Rev Med Interne 2018.
9. Daniluk JC, Koert E. Childless women's beliefs and knowledge about oocyte freezing for social and medical reasons. Hum Reprod. 2016;31(10):2313-2320.
10. Sayan M, Cassidy RJ, Butker EE, Nanda RH, Krishnamurti L, Khan MK, Esiashvili N. Gonadal shielding technique to preserve fertility in male pediatric patients treated with total body irradiation for stem cell transplantation. Bone Marrow Transplant. 2016;51(7):997-998.
11. Saraf AJ, Nahata L. Fertility counseling and preservation: considerations for the pediatric endocrinologist. Transl Pediatr. 2017;6(4):313-322.
12. Donnez J, Dolmans MM. Fertility Preservation in Women. N Engl J Med. 2018;378(4):400-401.
13. Hirshfeld-Cytron J, Gracia C, Woodruff TK. Nonmalignant diseases and treatments associated with primary ovarian failure: an expanded role for fertility preservation. J Womens Health (Larchmt). 2011;20(10):1467-1477.
14. Shirasawa H, Terada Y. In vitro maturation of human immature oocytes for fertility preservation and research material. Reprod Med Biol. 2017;16(3):258-267.
15. Kanda Y, Wada H, Yamasaki R, Kawamura K, Ishihara Y, Sakamoto K, Ashizawa M, Sato M, Machishima T, Terasako-Saito K, Kimura S, Nakasone H, Kikuchi M, Yamazaki R, Kanda J, Kako S, Nishida J, Tsunoda H, Omori Y, Nakazawa M, Tanaka O. Protection of ovarian function by two distinct methods of ovarian shielding for young female patients who receive total body irradiation. Ann Hematol. 2014;93(2):287-292.
16. Senra JC, Roque M, Talim MCT, Reis FM, Tavares RLC. Gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonists for ovarian protection during cancer chemotherapy: systematic review and meta-analysis. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2018;51(1):77-86.
17. Vassena R, Eguizabal C, Heindryckx B, Sermon K, Simon C, van Pelt AM, Veiga A, Zambelli F; ESHRE special interest group Stem Cells. Stem cells in reproductive medicine: ready for the patient? Hum Reprod. 2015;30(9):2014-2021.
"Patients must be aware that laws and regulations from other countries will likely be different from home"
Author: Raquel Pillado
WHAT IS “CROSS BORDER REPRODUCTIVE CARE”?
Accessibility of patients suffering from infertility to appropriate treatments may greatly vary depending on which country or region they reside in. The availability of appropriate care, its quality, cost or regulatory restrictions may push patients into seeking treatment abroad (2). Furthermore, these limitations may also include privacy issues, involving the social stigma that may be associated with certain treatments (surrogacy, sex selection, preimplantation genetic diagnosis…) in certain cultures. Such situation is known as Cross Border Reproductive Care (CBRC), and it is defined as the practice of travelling to another region or to a different country to receive fertility treatments (3). CBRC is also commonly known as reproductive, procreative or fertility tourism because many patients take the chance to combine their fertility treatments with regular tourist activities. Also, some authors refer to this phenomenon as “reproductive exile”, because they see it as the patient being pushed to this alternative in order to achieve their desire to become parents (4).
PREFERRED DESTINATIONS FOR CBRC
The destination choice often represents an arduous task for patients due the travel logistics, including the geographical and cultural proximity and the specificities of treatments required (5). As a result, some companies have appeared to offer assistance for patients interested in CBRC. These companies help their clients to organize their trip, from accommodation booking to arranging all medical meetings. Moreover, some clinics directly advertise specific programs for international clients, and they even include sections on their websites specifically dedicated to provide information on every step of the process and tourist attractions.
Nowadays, the main global markets or hubs for CBRC industry are Denmark for sperm donation, Belgium for in vitro fertilization (IVF) or Spain and Czech Republic for egg and embryo donation. Likewise, the most popular destinations for fertility preservation seem to be Denmark and Belgium in Europe and the United States in the American continent. This country is also a preferred choice for cryopreservation of gametes, embryos and ovarian and testicular tissues. Furthermore, and along with Russia and India, it is a popular destination for preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) and sex selection procedures (3).
The selected country depends on where patients are originally from and the treatment they seek (Table 1). For example, North Americans visit countries with comparative lower prices, Britons travel to other European countries looking for sperm, eggs and embryo donors and some Arab couples engage in “return reproductive tourism”* (6) to the Middle East (5).
FACTORS TO CONSIDER BEFORE TRAVELLING ABROAD FOR CBRC
Patients must be aware that laws and regulations from other countries will likely be different from home. There are two main ways of regulating the practice and the access to ART. First, proper regulation can be achieved through sets of rules or guidelines followed by the practitioners on a voluntary basis. Usually these guidelines are developed by professional organizations related to the field. Secondly, governmental legislation, which implies specific rules in the shape of laws ruling the use of ART and legal penalties for those who violate them (7).
It is important to study the specific ART legislation and/or guidelines of both the origin and chosen destination countries. In order to find information about these regulations the first step is to find out whether there is a national independent regulator overseeing ART practice. For example, in the United States, United Kingdom and India these are the American Society of Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) (8), the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (9), and the National Registry of Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Clinics and Banks (10), respectively. These organizations usually provide information concerning national legislation and/or guidelines, and some of them even offer data of officially approved clinics. In the case of the US and UK there are legislation and guidelines, while in India there are only guidelines (6). Regarding this country, the National Registry is still in the process of verifying whether clinics follow these guidelines and awarding them with official certificates accordingly (10).
The information obtained from guidelines/legislation will provide a general idea about the standards required for ART in those countries. When looking for a gestational carrier or sperm, eggs or embryos donors, it is important to specifically look into the requirements asked to potential donors and gestational carriers (genetic tests, STD reports, etc.). Additionally, in the case of surrogacy it is also advisable to double check any law related to legal rights over the offspring, both in the surrogate mother and the couple´s respective countries of origin (for more information about surrogacy, read one of our previous posts here).
Lastly, the language barrier must not be forgotten. Before travelling, one should verify with the fertility centre the availability of interpreters and the ability of the staff to speak the required language. Also, it will be necessary to ask the centre to provide copies of every document in that language (certificates, bills, informed consents, etc.).
THE FUTURE OF CBRC
Travelling between countries and easy access to information is nowadays part of our routine life due to globalization and internet. As a result, it is very attractive for assisted reproduction clinics to offer their services to international clients. However this market has quickly developed without any international regulation ruling over it. As a future objective to improve CBRC, governs and health organizations should work on an international regulation in order to protect both patients and professionals (2). Ideally, the creation of an international joint database and standardization of data collection would help to improve ART efficiency (11). In addition, special attention should be given to writing up laws in order to:  prevent exploitation of gamete donors and/or gestational carriers in destination countries; and  avoid the price rise that would make it more difficult for local patients to access ART treatments.
Even though CBRC seems to provide a solution for most patients to access to certain treatments, this option needs a much clearer international regulation. Such improvement should help to collect data to increase the current knowledge on ART field, which will enable professionals to offer a better care in the future. Furthermore, governments should probably implement specific measurements to prevent misinformation to international patients. Simultaneously, this would help defending local citizens from exploitation in specific cases; for instance, those in which a third party is involved such as gestational carriers or donors.
Finally, the decision of signing on CBRC should be made after extensive research about the treatment one wishes to undergo and the regulations in the destination country.
*Situation in which a couple or an individual who lives abroad returns home specifically for ART treatments due to a variety of cultural, moral and psychological reasons (6).
1. https://www.babygest.es/turismo-reproductivo/que-es-el-turismo-reproductivo-o-de-fertilidad/ (10-03-2018)
2. Storrow RF (2011) Assisted reproduction on treacherous terrain: the legal hazards of cross-border reproductive travel. Reproductive BioMedicine Online (2011) 23, 538– 545.
3. Salama M (2014) Cross Border Reproductive Care (CBRC): A Global Perspective. Obstet Gynecol Int J 1(2): 00008. DOI: 10.15406/ ogij.2014.01.00008.
4. Inhorn and Patrizio (2009) Rethinking reproductive ‘‘tourism’’ as reproductive ‘‘exile’’, American Society for Reproductive Medicine, Fert and Steril, 92 (3): 904-906.
5. Gürtin ZB et al (2011) Introduction: travelling for conception and the global assisted reproduction market. Reprod Biomed Online, 23(5): 535-537.
6. Inhorn MC (2011) Diasporic dreaming: return reproductive tourism to the Middle East. Reprod Biomed Online, 23(5): 582 - 91.
7. Präg P and Mills MC (2017) Assisted Reproductive Technology in Europe: Usage and Regulation in the Context of Cross-Border Reproductive Care. In: Kreyenfeld M, Konietzka D (eds) Childlessness in Europe: Contexts, Causes, and Consequences. Demographic Research Monographs (A series of the Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research). Springer, Cham.
8. American Society For Reproductive Medicine. Montgomery Highway Birmingham, Alabama. Availability: http://www.asrm.org/arm/
9. Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority. 10 Spring Gardens London Availability: https://www.hfea.gov.uk/treatments/eexplor-all-treatments/fertility-treatment-abroad/
10. National Registry of Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Clinics and Banks in India. ICMR. Ansari Nagar, New Delhi Availability: http://www.icmr.nic.in/icmrnews/art/art.htm
11. Shenfield F (2011) Implementing a good practice guide for CBRC: perspectives from the ESHRE Cross-Border Reproductive Care Taskforce. Reprod BioMed Online 23: 657– 664.
“Most of the couples with no children are found in developing countries".
Author: Iñaki Arroyos
Nowadays, assisted reproduction technologies (ART) are routine medical procedures that help couples with problems to conceive naturally. Since the birth of Louise Brown in 1978, the first in vitro fertilization (IVF) baby, important advances in the field of infertility have been achieved. For instance, ovulation can now be controlled by the use of modern and improved drugs, and the latest enhancements in culture conditions allow to better mimic the actual natural environment for embryo development. Additionally, in recent years new technologies have arisen that allow to perform better embryo selection, and remarkable progress in cryopreservation has been achieved, too, thus resulting in improved pregnancy rates for current treatments.
Nevertheless and in spite of these advances, there is still progress to be made: what kind of challenges will ART face in the upcoming years? The following points are three of these challenges:
2. In vitro-generated gametes
3. ART in developing countries
FUTURE CHALLENGES TO FACE
A biomarker is defined as “a characteristic that is objectively measured and evaluated as an indicator of normal biologic processes, pathogenic processes, or pharmacologic responses to a therapeutic intervention” (2). Biomarkers are important in reproductive medicine because of their potential to: (a) reveal different causes of infertility; and (b) improve treatments and clinical outcomes. Consequently, research on biomarkers is quite an active area in reproduction and other medicine disciplines.
The term OMICS collectively refers to a group of technologies that aim to study different types of molecules and their relation with biological functions. Relevant examples of such areas are epigenomics, genomics, transcriptomics, proteomics and metabolomics, among others (3). The appearance of these research fields helped scientist to find new biomarkers for different subjects. However, regarding reproduction medicine this effort has resulted uncoordinated (4), and so there is currently a lack of studies able to validate the actual quality of biomarkers. Within the huge area of research on ART biomarkers, two topics of paramount importance are presented below:
1. Embryo selection
A key factor in IVF is to determine which embryo exhibits the highest implantation potential. Even though a great progress has been made in order to clarify the process of embryo development, the actual physiology of embryos and the contributing factors for successful implantation are not yet entirely understood.
Embryos generated in the laboratory present different implantation potential to each other (5); it just so happens that embryologists may not know for sure which embryo has the highest implantation potential for transfer. This leads to performing multiple embryo transfers that may result in multiple pregnancies, which entail associated problems such as increased perinatal mortality for twins and triplets (6). In order to avoid such problems, different embryo scoring systems have been developed to allow a better and more accurate embryo selection. However, since these systems are based on morphological traits they do not offer objective and reliable data, and so classification can actually vary depending on the observer.
The introduction of time-lapse allowed to follow embryo development from zygote state up to blastocyst in a continuous fashion. Additionally, the improved culture conditions have made possible to perform single embryo transfer (SET) much more frequently, which avoids multiple pregnancies. These advances undoubtedly represented a leap forward in ART, and yet sometimes there are still difficulties when it comes to selecting the best embryo. The development of OMICS unveiled the existence of a series of factors that may improve embryo selectivity, although related new technologies are actually far from being used on a daily basis in the clinical world.
2. Sperm biomarkers
Male fertility problems represent approximately 50% of infertility (7), reason why it is important to accurately diagnose male factor disorders. Semen analysis is currently one of the most common tools for sperm assessment; however, even though it is certainly helpful for making a primary diagnosis, it lacks objectivity and accuracy (8). In fact, false negatives are occasionally reported to patients who still fail to conceive. Perhaps the most successful approach to improve semen analyses has been finding certain biomarkers that provide extra information about sperm quality.
Spermatozoa are not just a means to deliver the paternal genetic material into the oocyte, but they also provide instructions for the proper embryo development. Such instructions are epigenetically encoded, which means the genome is modified depending on the association and regulation of specific proteins to DNA. For instance, differences in protamin ratio (proteins essential for DNA compaction in the sperm nucleus) have been found between fertile and infertile men (9). Other proteins found in the seminal plasma may also serve as biomarkers for the regulation of specific genes, thus improving the accuracy of semen analyses. Taken together, these and other similar observations make reasonable to think that epigenomics and proteomics may provide useful information for sperm assessment.
The use of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) has expanded during the last years. However, there is still a need of a biomarker able to discriminate which individual spermatozoa is the most suitable for injection. Different methods based on the quality of sperm DNA or percentage of cell death in a given semen population have been developed, and yet they are not able to select the best individual sperm for ICSI.
2. In vitro-generated gametes
What about those patients who constantly fail to conceive through IVF or who have lost the capacity to produce gametes due to a disease or a specific condition such as some sort of cancer? Will they actually have any chance in the future to pass on their genetic material? Stem cells may provide an answer for these people.
Stem cells have the potential to generate any type of cell in the organism. In order to generate artificial gametes, two types of stem cells can be used:
1. Adult stem cells from male and female gonads (that naturally differentiate into either sperm or eggs).
2. Pluripotent stem cells. Two types: i) embryonic stem cells (ESCs), derived from the inner cell mass of the embryo (10) and able to generate any cell lineage; and ii) induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs), obtained from somatic cells by overexpression of specific genes (11, 12), which can also turn them into any type of cell.
Despite previous achievements in generating gametes from somatic cells in mice, there are serious technical and ethical issues that nowadays keep this approach away from the clinical practice.
However, this scientific breakthrough represented new challenges in ART:
- Transplantation of stem cells into gonads may be no longer necessary, but gamete development in the laboratory still requires certain factors to substitute the function of ovaries and testes.
- Molecular interactions and signalling pathways are different in men and mice, and so improving the technique is absolutely necessary. “Cells from a man’s skin could theoretically be used to create eggs that are fertilized with a partner’s sperm, then nurtured in the womb of a surrogate” (1). This science-fiction scenario may be actually possible within the next twenty-five years.
3. ART in developing countries
Epidemiological studies show that the majority of couples with no children live in developing countries (13). By contrast, high-quality ART treatments are almost exclusively performed in western countries (14). Developing countries still have quite a limited offer of treatments due to their high cost (15).
Among all technologies available in developing countries, IVF constitutes the main treatment, followed by intrauterine insemination (IUI). However, these techniques are still unaffordable for the majority of the population in certain countries. Over the years, different strategies have arisen to provide more affordable solutions. The addition of natural cycles (16) or minimal/mild stimulations in order to reduce the amounts of hormones (17), in combination with intravaginal culture of oocytes (INVO) (18) or new developed devices offer reachable alternatives at a lower cost (19).
High prices of treatments is not the only reason of the slow progress of ART in developing countries. Their fertility issues have not drawn western countries’ attention, and so interest in this research field has decreased. Overpopulation is, perhaps, one of the main reasons; countries lacking a well-developed social structure (healthcare or education, among others) and a strong economy able to sustain the present population should not foster population growth. On the contrary, it should be controlled; by doing so, life quality of next generations could be guaranteed. Additionally, developing areas have other priorities as thousands of people are still suffering from diseases such as malaria, tuberculosis or HIV. Interesting enough is the fact that the main cause for infertility is the high incidence of pelvic infections; therefore, approaches to reduce fertility issues in these countries should be firstly focused on decreasing sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) (20).
Within the last forty years assisted reproduction has experienced a true revolution. Looking back in time, seventy years ago all these approaches could have been regarded as science fiction, but nowadays infertility can be effectively treated. Whereas the main disadvantage is the high cost of assisted reproduction procedures, new lines of research are currently focused on reducing it, and new methodologies are becoming more easily available. Perhaps, in twenty-five years, ART as a whole maybe a worldwide affordable approach.
1. Cyranosky D. Stem cells: Egg engineers. Nature. 2013; 500:392-394.
2. Woodcock J. Assessing the clinical utility of diagnostics used in drug therapy. Clin Pharmacol Ther. 2010; 88:765–73.
3. Rocío Rivera Egea, Nicolás Garrido Puchalt, Marcos Messeguer Escrivá, Alex C Varghese. OMICS: Current and future perspectives in reproductive medicine and technology. Journal of Human Reproductive Sciences. 2014; 7(2): 73-92.
4. Palmer Stephen S, Barnhart Kurt T. Biomarkers in Reproductive Medicine: The promise, and can it be fulfilled? Fertil Steril. 2013; 99(4): 954-962.
5. Bromer JG, Seli E. Assessment of embryo viability in assisted reproductive technologies: shortcomings of current approaches and the emerging role of metabolomics. Curr Opin Obstet Gynecol. 2008; 20:234-241.
6. Lieberman B, Ali R, and Rangarajan S. Towards the elective replacement of a single embryo transfer (eSET) in the United Kingdom. Human Fertility. 2007; 10(2):123-7.
7. Mosher WD, Pratt WF. Fecundity and infertility in the United States: incidence and trends. Fertil Steril.1991; 56:192-3.
8. Murray KS, James A, McGeady JB, Reed ML, Kuang WW, et al. The effect of the new 2010 World Health Organization criteria for semen analysis on male infertility. Fertil Steril 2012; 98:1428-31.
9. Carrell DT, Liu L. Altered protamine 2 expression is uncommon in donors of known fertility, but common among men with poor fertilizing capacity, and may reflect other abnormalities of spermiogenesis. J Androl 2001; 22:604-10.
10. Aguilar-Gallardo C, Poo M, Gomez E, Galan A, Sanchez E, Marques-Mari A, et al. Derivation, characterization, differentiation, and registration of seven human embryonic stem cell lines (VAL-3, -4, -5, -6M, -7, -8, and -9) on human feeder. In Vitro Cell Dev Biol Anim 2010; 46:317-26.
11. Takahashi K, Yamanaka S. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from mouse embryonic and adult broblast cultures by de ned factors. Cell 2006; 126:663-76.
12. Yu J, Vodyanik MA, Smuga-Otto K, Antosiewicz-Bourget J, Frane JL, Tian S, et al. Induced pluripotent stem cell lines derived from human somatic cells. Science 2007; 318:1917-20.
13. Rutstein SO, Iqbal HS. Infecundity, Infertility and Childessness in Developing Countries. DHS Comparative Reports, WHO. 2004; p24.
14. Sharma S, Mittal S, Aggarwal P. Management of infertility in low resources countries. BJOG. 2009; 116 (Suppl1): 77-83.
15. Murage A, Muteshi MC, Githae F. Assisted reproduction services provision in a developing country: time to act? Fertil Steril. 2011; 96(4):966-8.
16. Shahin AY. The problem of IVF cost in developing countries: has natural cycle IVF a place? Reprod Biomed Online. 2007; 15(1):51-6
17. Kim CH, Kim SR, Cheon YP, et al. Minimal stimulation using gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) antagonist and recombinant human follicle-stimulating hormone versus GNRH antagonist multiple-dose protocol in low responders undergoing in vitro fertilization/intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Fertil Steril. 2009; 92(6):2082-4
18. Lucena E, Saa AM, Navarro DE, et al. INVO procedure: minimally invasive IVF as an alternative treatment option for infertile couples. Sci World J. 2012; 2012:571-596.
19. Klerkx EPF, Janssen M, van Blerkom J et al. O-014. First pregnancies with a simplified IVF procedure: a crucial step to universal and accessible infertility care Human Reprod. Abstracts of the 29th Annual Meeting of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology 2013; 28(Suppl1):i4-i6.
20. Ombelet W. Global access to infertility care in developing countries: a case of human rights, equity and social justice. F, V& in ObGyn. 2011; 3(4):257-266.
"Only a small fraction of oocytes will reach the correct maturation stage and acquire the potential to be released and fertilized".
Author: Edel Rocher
Figure 1. Representation of the parallel growth of follicles and maturation status of oocytes. During embryo development, germ cells are associated to each other in multinucleated cell accumulation called cysts. Each of these cysts contains multiple oogonia, the cells that will eventually become the oocytes. At birth, oogonia are already individualized as oocytes and surrounded by ovarian cells, forming a structure called primordial follicle. Some of the follicles eventually grow due to proliferation of the oocyte-surrounding cells (follicular cells), while oocyte development continues. For this to occur, an intricate balance of hormonal actions is needed, whose main characters are FSH and LH (modified from ).
During assisted reproduction treatments ("cycles"), immature oocytes (or eggs) are oftentimes found. The following lines try to explain the reader why these cells are so frequent, and why they reduce the success rates of fertility treatments.
The egg or oocyte is part of a cell aggregation found in the ovary referred to as follicle. Follicles receive and produce a series of hormone secretions that contribute to the maturation of these eggs, which are eventually released during ovulation.
At birth, women normally present somewhat between 1 and 2 million ovarian follicles. These are called primordial follicles, each containing a primary oocyte (Figure 1). Only a small fraction of these oocytes will reach the correct maturation stage and acquire the potential to be released and fertilized. Oocytes and spermatozoa, the gametes, undergo a special kind of cell division called meiosis, which consists of two consecutive divisions, the end result being the reduction of the chromosome number to half. This means that, in the germline, a diploid human cell (46 chromosomes) eventually gives rise to four haploid cells (23 chromosomes each). During fertilization, each haploid gamete contributes half of the chromosome complement, thus generating a normal embryo.
In a newborn, primary oocytes are paused at the beginning of the meiotic division (“meiotic arrest”), and remain so throughout childhood. Early stages of oocyte development include the germinal vesicle (GV) and metaphase I (MI) stages (Figure 2). Because these stages are part of the first meiotic division, the cell is still diploid and, therefore, it is still considered "immature".
Once puberty is reached, a pituitary gonadotropin called follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) promotes the growth of a cohort of follicles every month. But only those at the right stage of maturation will go on, along with their respective oocyte, which comes out of the arrest and resumes meiosis. By the time ovulation occurs, triggered by the surge of the luteinizing hormone (LH), oocytes have already completed the first of the two meiotic divisions, which means the primary oocyte has already divided into two cells: the first polar body and the secondary oocyte. The former is just a small cell that contains the corresponding chromosomes that result from the cell division. It never participates in embryogenesis, and so it has no genetic contribution to it. The latter in turn continues through the second meiotic division, until it arrests at MII (metaphase II) stage before ovulation (Figure 2). These oocytes (eggs) are considered mature, and they can be fertilized by sperm once ovulated. However, if fertilization does not occur, meiosis is never completed in the oocyte (2).
MAIN ASPECTS NEEDED FOR THE EGG TO ACHIEVE FULL MATURATION
Follicle growth and oocyte maturation are both influenced by circulating levels of gonadotropins (FSH and LH) and steroids (progesterone and oestrogens), among other factors. As parallel processes in time, they should accomplish certain events to ensure the formation of a fully mature egg by the time the follicle has acquired its maximum size ("Graafian follicle" = 18-21 mm) (3). Maturation status of the oocyte is defined by:
1. Nuclear maturation of the egg. This means the oocyte needs to reach a specific stage of meiotic division (MII stage), thus ensuring the appropriate chromosome number (genetic material) has been achieved (4).
2. Cytoplasmic maturation. In addition to the organization of the genetic material, the oocyte must complete a series of events such as distribution of mitochondria (the power source of the cell) or formation and relocation of the cortical granules (which will play a key role during fertilization), among others. This will guarantee the readiness of the egg for the sperm arrival (4).
3. Follicle maturation and growth. The follicle must increase its volume accordingly with the progression of the oocyte maturation; follicular cells are to be reorganized and differentiate into distinct layers to ensure blood supply and facilitate communication with the egg. Should any of these events fail to complete, fertilization will be greatly compromised (5).
Figure 2. Different stages of oocyte maturation. (A) Germinal vesicle (GV). The nucleus of the oocyte is still visible at an eccentric location (arrow), indicative of an early stage of meiosis. (B) Metaphase I (MI). The nuclear envelope has disorganized and the chromosomes (not seen) are preparing for division. No other evident features can be clearly distinguished under the optical microscope. (C) Metaphase II (MII). First division of meiosis has been completed, evidenced by the presence of the first polar body (arrow). The oocyte is now arrested at the second division; the nucleus is not distinguishable because chromosomes are again prepared for division, should fertilization happen. 400x magnification (original images modified from ).
POSSIBLE CAUSES FOR FAILURE IN EGG MATURATION DURING ASSISTED REPRODUCTION TREATMENTS
During assisted reproduction cycles, women are subjected to controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (COH) by the application of a variety of protocols in order to promote the growth of multiple follicles. One of the main actors used in these stimulation protocols is the human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG), which causes the oocyte to progress through meiosis and take over the role of LH in triggering ovulation (7).
The use of conventional protocols allows most of the oocytes obtained to be at MII stage by the time of egg collection. However, some of these eggs could remain immature despite ovarian stimulation (8). Some estimations have suggested that around 20%-30% of collected oocytes do not achieve full maturation (9), although such figures may actually be higher as a consequence of the stimulation of multiple follicles. In some rare cases, it is possible to observe a phenomenon known as "oocyte maturation arrest", in which oocytes keep arrested during the maturation process, thus not being able to complete it. As a result, there is an increased number of collected oocytes actually arrested at either GV or MI stage (10).
Explanations for these rare cases include several possibilities:
1. It could be due to failure in ovarian stimulation response. Both LH activity and hCG timing are directly related to the meiotic progression of oocytes, so the abnormal function of the hormone stimulation mechanisms may negatively impact clinical outcomes. In these cases, results might be improved by the modification of doses, hCG forms or stimulation protocols in successive cycles (11).
2. Specific follicular cells may present defective signalling mechanisms, which would result in abnormal response to gonadotropins and the subsequent inability of the egg to progress through meiosis (12,13).
3. Oocytes unable to reach a minimum size cannot progress further than GV or MI stage. In those cases, the growth of the follicle is limited, which means follicular cells do not acquire the ability to respond to gonadotrophic signals and promote maturation up to MII stage of the oocyte (13).
4. The acquisition of "meiotic competence" is controlled by the so-called maturation promoting factor (MPF). The activity of this molecular machinery may be compromised in certain patients suffering from rare heritable molecular defects. In such cases, the end result could be the inability of oocytes to reach the mature stage (14).
In spite of these hypotheses, only a few cases of oocyte maturation failure in ART treatments have actually been reported (11). Additionally, the modification of hCG doses, in vitro maturation (IVM) of oocytes and intracytoplasmic injection of MPF seem to be the best options to date to overcome meiotic arrest (15). Even in the most difficult cases, egg donation may be a potential solution.
The approaches mentioned above are just suggestions and theoretical solutions; this means further research is needed in order to improve our knowledge on the actual causes for oocyte maturation failure. Only by doing so will we be able to better deal with this situation.
"Chromosome organization has been proposed to have potential functional implications in male fertility".
Author: Lidón Carretero Vilarroig
WHAT ARE TELOMERES?
Telomeres are nucleoprotein complexes located at both ends of linear chromosomes. In the case of vertebrates, there are hundreds of tandem repeats of the sequence TTAGGG. Together with their protein complex, telomeres play a very important role in stability and replication of chromosomes, preventing their breakage and regulating recombination between homologs (1, 2). Telomere length (TL) is determined by various loci located on several autosomes and on the X chromosome. In addition, factors such as age, gender and free radical levels have an effect on TL, as well as specifically the age of the father at the time of conception of the offspring (3). Meyerson et al estimated that the mean TL varies between 5 and 10 kb in somatic cells, and between 10 and 20 kb in germ cells, depending on the species and cell type studied (4). However, in somatic cells telomeres suffer from shortening in each round of replication; this is due to the inability of the DNA polymerase, the enzyme in charge of synthesising DNA, to elongate the 5’ end (known as “End Replication Problem”) (5). By contrast, germ cells count on an active enzyme able to solve this problem: the telomerase. Nevertheless, this enzyme is only active in specific cell lines, stem cells and immortal cancer cells.
TELOMERES IN SPERM CELLS
Telomeres play a main role in the organization of chromosomes inside the nucleus of sperm cells, since they take up specific non-random positions (6, 7) (Fig. 2). Although different models have been proposed to explain chromosome organization inside the sperm nucleus, it is well accepted the idea that every chromosome has a particular position, known as chromosome territory (Fig. 2) (7). Some authors have described a dynamic length during spermatogenesis: telomeres shorten during the early stages of sperm differentiation, whereas by the end of the process they elongate again, even exceeding their starting length (8).
It is also known the importance of telomeres in chromosome recognition during cell division. They regulate recombination of homologous chromosomes and seem to be the first structure from the paternal nuclear genome to respond to signals after fertilization, leading to pronucleus formation (1, 2).
SPERM CELL TELOMERES AND MALE INFERTILITY
Telomeres have been targeted as potential candidates to explain some cases of infertility, since they are one of the epigenetic regulatory mechanisms required for proper embryogenesis (9). Due to the fact that telomeres are directly involved in chromosome recognition during cell division, modifications in the structure and length of telomeres may be related to abnormal chromosomal dotation (10). Shorter telomeres in spermatozoa may be a leading cause of aneuploidy (11), being this related to recurrent pregnancy loss. The proper organization and length of telomeres contribute to an accurate cell division, thus generating sperm cells with the right chromosome complement.
Regarding their arrangement inside the nucleus, chromosome territories are thought to be organized in such a way that they allow for the actual interaction between genes from different chromosomes. Given the importance of such interactions, chromosome organization has been proposed to have potential functional implications in male fertility.
Alterations in TL have been previously studied, suggesting a link between telomere shortening and errors during programmed cell death (apoptosis), sperm maturation and reduction in fertility (12, 13, 14). Also, DNA damage has been associated with disruption of the normal telomere–telomere interactions, leading to possible loss of the typical loop configuration of telomeres found in chromosomes. This would imply abnormalities in sperm chromosome deposition, activation and processing by the oocyte at the time of fertilization (15).
Several studies in mice have suggested the existence of a protective mechanism that would degrade spermatocytes with reduced telomere length to prevent their maturation. Should this checkpoint fail, defective spermatocytes with shortened telomeres would be able to progress through meiosis (the typical division of gamete precursors) (16, 17), thus resulting in potentially abnormal (non-functional) sperm cells.
Telomere length could be one of the causes to explain some cases of male infertility of unknown origin. Some authors have described shortened telomeres from both sperm and ova to have additive effect on limiting the potential growth of embryos. Despite all these considerations, the actual role of telomere length in male infertility remains to be further investigated.
1. Ozturk, S. Telomerase Activity and Telomere Length in Male Germ Cells. Biol. Reprod. 92, 53–53 (2015).
2. Bekaert, S., Derradji, H. & Baatout, S. Telomere biology in mammalian germ cells and during development. Dev. Biol. 274, 15–30 (2004).
3. Thilagavathi, J., Venkatesh, S. & Dada, R. Telomere length in reproduction. Andrologia 45, 289–304 (2013).
4. Meyerson, M. Role of telomerase in normal and cancer cells. J Clin Oncol 18, 2626–2634 (2000).
5. Rieko Ohki, Toshiki Tsurimoto and Fuyuki Ishikawa. In Vitro Reconstitution of the End Replication Problem. Molecular and cellular biology 2001 Sept. 2001, p. 5753–5766
6. Mudrak, O., Tomilin, N. & Zalensky, A. Chromosome architecture in the decondensing human sperm nucleus. J. Cell Sci. 118, 4541–4550 (2005).
7. Ioannou, Dimitrios; Millan, Nicole M.; Jordan, Elizabeth; Tempest, Helen G. A new model of sperm nuclear architecture following assessment of the organization of centromeres and telomeres in three-dimensions. Scientific Reports. 2017/01/31/online VOL7; 41585 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/srep41585 10.1038/srep41585
8. Tanemura, K. et al. Dynamic rearrangement of telomeres during spermatogenesis in mice. Dev. Biol. 281, 196–207 (2005).
9. Esteves SC. A clinical appraisal of the genetic basis in unexplained male infertility. Journal of Human Reproductive Sciences. 2013;6(3):176-182. doi:10.4103/0974-1208.121419.
10. Hanna, C. W. et al. Telomere length and reproductive aging. Hum. Reprod. 24, 1206–11 (2009).
11. Treff, N. R., Su, J., Taylor, D. & Scott, R. T. Telomere DNA deficiency is associated with development of human embryonic aneuploidy. PLoS Genet. 7,e1002161 (2011).
12. Fujisawa, M. et al. Telomerase activity in the testis of infertile patients with selected causes. Hum. Reprod. 13, 1476–9 (1998).
13. Cheng, E.-H. et al. Evaluation of telomere length in cumulus cells as a potential biomarker of oocyte and embryo quality. Hum. Reprod. 28, 929–36 (2013).
14. Moskovtsev, S. I., Willis, J., White, J. & Mullen, J. B. M. Disruption of telomere-telomere interactions associated with DNA damage in human spermatozoa. Syst. Biol. Reprod. Med. 56, 407–12 (2010).
15. Disruption of Telomere–Telomere Interactions Associated with DNA Damage in Human Spermatozoa. Sergey I. Moskovtsev, Jennifer Willis, John White & J. Brendan M. Mullen. Systems Biology in Reproductive Medicine Vol. 56 , Iss. 6,2010
16. Hemann MT, Rudolph KL, Strong MA, DePinho RA, Chin L, Greider CW. Telomere dysfunction triggers developmentally regulated germ cell apoptosis. Mol Biol Cell. 2001;12:2023–30.
17. Liu L, Blasco M, Trimarchi J, Keefe D. An essential role for functional telomeres in mouse germ cells during fertilization and early development. Dev Biol. 2002;249:74–84.
"You should take your time to consider all ethical issues
you may encounter within the process".
Author: Sara Sanz
The latest advances in assisted reproduction technologies have managed to make incredible things come true. Current advances are changing the lives of millions of people, giving them the opportunity to form their own family. One of the options that have opened new possibilities for parenthood is surrogacy. Perhaps, this is not as common as others, but it certainly hits the media every now and then. However, what have you heard about it? The following points are the main aspects everyone should know about this option:
A) Who may need surrogacy. Prospective parents are individuals who seek a surrogate mother because:
1. There is actually a medical condition that makes it impossible or dangerous for the woman to get pregnant and/or to enter labour.
2. He is a single man who wants to become a father (2).
3. They are a gay men couple who want to form a family with a genetic link (3).
B) Who is the surrogate mother, and how does the entire process usually take place? The surrogate mother is a woman who carries out a pregnancy as a donation in order to help form a new life. This process can take place with or without her own eggs. If it is her eggs that are used, the process is referred to as traditional surrogacy; otherwise, it is called full or gestational surrogacy. If this is the case, embryos can be derived from three different sources (4):
1. Eggs and sperm that belong to the intended parents.
2. Donor eggs fertilized by the sperm of the intended father.
3. Both eggs and sperm obtained from donors.
C) Whether surrogacy entails remuneration depends on the country. If the surrogate mother does not receive a payment (although prospective parents may provide reimbursement for medical care), the arrangement is known as non-commercial surrogacy, which is common between family members or friends. On the contrary, if the surrogate mother does receive compensation, the term used for the arrangement is commercial surrogacy (5).
D) Where this procedure may be carried out depending on local regulations. As shown above (Fig. 1), surrogacy is only allowed in certain countries, each one with its own legal regulations. For instance, some of them only permit the altruistic form, in others surrogacy is available just for resident citizens, and in some others this option is only allowed for heterosexual couples. Therefore, it is essential to know which country/countries present the appropriate legislation in each particular case, reason why before choosing a destination it is important to find out some key aspects, such as (6):
E) Perhaps the first question to ask actually is: "does this option feel right for me? Every single person and situation are unique, and so you may end up wondering whether this is the right path to form your family. Regarding such a delicate topic you should first question yourself, and carefully take your time to consider all ethical issues you may encounter within the process.
It is important to consider that there exist multiple support groups and agencies that can help you resolve all your technical and ethical doubts with respect to this process. Therefore, it is advisable to first gather all available information in order to answer every question. Only then would it be safe to achieve your dream of starting a family the way you decide.
1. Surrogacy. In: Wikipedia [Internet]. 2017. Available from: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Surrogacy&oldid=810900302.
2. Carone N, Baiocco R, Lingiardi V. Single fathers by choice using surrogacy: why men decide to have a child as a single parent. Hum Reprod Oxf Engl. 2017 Sep 1;32(9):1871–9.
3. Blake L, Carone N, Raffanello E, Slutsky J, Ehrhardt AA, Golombok S. Gay fathers’ motivations for and feelings about surrogacy as a path to parenthood. Hum Reprod Oxf Engl. 2017 01;32(4):860–7.
4. Humbyrd C. Fair trade international surrogacy. Dev World Bioeth. 2009 Dec;9(3):111–8.
5. Raposo VL. The new Portuguese law on surrogacy - The story of how a promising law does not really regulate surrogacy arrangements. JBRA Assist Reprod. 2017 Sep 1;21(3):230–9.
6. Families through Surrogacy. Available from: http://www.familiesthrusurrogacy.com/
Potential effects of different factors on the reproductive health of men and women. How does lifestyle affect fertility?
"A series of different factors in lifestyle can be altered in order to enhance the overall welfare (...) they play a key role in determining our reproductive health (...)".
Author: Noemi Díaz Arróniz
Infertility is considered a clinical condition, defined (by consensus) by the failure to achieve natural pregnancy after one year of unprotected sexual intercourse (1). It implies serious psychological consequences, and so it results in a stressful experience for infertile couples (2). The prevalence of infertility has increased since 1955, and nowadays it affects at least 15% of couples in reproductive age (1, 2).
A series of different factors in lifestyle can be altered in order to enhance the overall welfare. It is important to remember that these factors are ultimately under our own control, because they play a key role in determining our reproductive health and they can positively or negatively affect fertility (1). The concept "quality of life" (QOL) refers to the well-being of individuals, and it is affected by both individual and social factors (3).
Here we report the potential effects of different lifestyle factors on the reproductive health of men and women. Even though many aspects of life are not subjected to modification, lifestyle itself may be changed for good (1).
1. TIMELINE OF REPRODUCTION: ADVANCED AGE.
Advanced maternal age is a risk factor for fertility, and it has been reported to be directly related to a variety of problems, such as pregnancy loss, obstetric complications, foetal anomalies and different genetic conditions like Down syndrome.
Due to changes in lifestyle, economic factors, social environment, or the will to grow professionally and acquire a proper education level, numerous couples currently choose to delay their parenthood. This implies that the age to father children becomes slowly (but inevitably) higher (1).
Advanced age negatively influences the clinical pregnancy rate after in vitro fertilization (IVF). In particular, this responds to an increased rate of embryo aneuploidies. Several studies have shown a direct relationship between the risk of foetal loss and the age of women older than 35 (5).
It is of no surprise that the current rhythm and lifestyle generates high levels of anxiety, and alterations of the endocrine system can seriously affect fertility (1). Both folliculogenesis and spermatogenesis (production of eggs in the ovaries and sperm in the testes, respectively) are strictly regulated by several hormones, and so any alteration of the hormone balance may have immediate negative effects on the quality of eggs and/or semen (5). It is also worth remembering that the stress caused by the frustration of not achieving pregnancy can directly affect hormone levels and, consequently, impede conception in first place (1).
Taking care of nutrition habits is essential not only for the overall health, but also for reproductive health (7). A balanced diet can help to improve fertility and reproductive potential for both men and women. The lack of specific elements or nutrients may eventually derive in some degree of infertility (2). As an example, it is always recommended to have a regular intake of food rich in antioxidants, such as fruit, vegetables, fibre, carotenoids.... (1). Besides containing antioxidants and essential nutrients, vitamins and folate are found in fruit and vegetables; these substances are involved in DNA and RNA synthesis, and thus play an important role in spermatogenesis by protecting the sperm DNA from free radical damage (7).
Modifying dietary habits can affect ovarian function, which can be correlated with changes in the concentration of circulating hormones including insulin and leptin. These hormones are tightly associated with the initiation and synchronisation of follicle growth, and it seems that its production is regulated, at least partially, by oestrogen secreted by the developing follicle.
It is also advisable to minimise the intake of saturated fats and cholesterol, to avoid excess that might affect the production and balance of sexual steroid hormones like progesterone. Insulin and leptin, in turn, are also associated with the proper initiation of menses; young girls with the wrong levels of certain hormones may see their menarche delayed or even suppressed.
Maintaining a healthy body weight is also essential for the optimal reproductive potential. A reduced index of body fat may impede the regular ovarian cycle in women. Also, obesity is one of the factors with a high impact on fertility, and one of the main causes of adverse effects on the early development of the embryo, too. Numerous studies have demonstrated a direct relationship between excess body mass and the diminished reproductive capacity (1).
On one hand, obesity increases the probability of suffering from miscarriage due to endocrine and metabolic alterations. It affects the quality of eggs and, subsequently, the embryos formed after fertilization (which may also result in severe developmental problems for the neonates). And on the other hand, an excessively low body mass index (BMI) also reduces the chances of pregnancy due to hormone imbalance and the inability to produce specific sexual hormones, which in turn cause abnormal menstrual cycles and obstetric complications (7).
4. TOBACCO AND ALCOHOL
The ingestion of toxic substances like tobacco, alcohol and other drugs has a potentially harmful effect on both oocytes and sperm. In men, consumption of alcohol has been linked with several negative side effects, such as testicular atrophy, decreased libido and reduced sperm count (1, 2). These symptoms are also typically found on those men who present steroid abuse (like in some cases of bodybuilders) (8). Alcohol use during pregnancy is an established cause of foetal alcohol syndrome (FAS). Several studies have recommended that pregnant women should avoid alcohol during pregnancy. In recent years it has consistently been shown that one drink (or more) per day or more increases the risk of spontaneous abortion, intrauterine growth retardation and low birth weight. An increased alcohol intake intake may reduce birth length and head circumference, cause preterm birth, defects in development and cognitive problems (9).
Nicotine abuse, in turn, may impede sperm motility and affect their overall viability. But high consumption of tobacco may also cause genetic alteration in ovocytes and, therefore, in embryos derived from them (2).
Women seeking to get pregnant are normally limited their coffee intake up to no more than 2-3 cups per day. Again, the abuse of caffeine may result in higher probabilities of suffering from a miscarriage (2, 8).
5. ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS
Exposure to certain chemical substances like pesticides or simply heavy metals may disturb the hormonal balance and negatively impact fertility. This is particularly evident in men; modern lifestyle features including pollution, large urban areas or industry have left their impact on the capacity of producing sperm within the last decades (2).
For instance, direct and continued exposure to heat sources or radiation have a direct effect on sperm DNA fragmentation and motility, which are some of the main features to be assessed in semen analyses. Not surprisingly, the reduced quality of sperm has been documented in men having close and long exposure to mobile devices like laptops and even ovens or saunas (7).
6. PHYSICAL EXERCISE
The regular practice of sports and moderate intensity exercise is beneficial and helpful when it comes to maintain a healthy weight, but also to reduce the levels of stress and anxiety (6). Men who exercise at least three times a week for one hour have been reported to score higher in almost all sperm parameters, compared to men who participated in a more frequent and intense physical activity (1).
Also, and as it has been previously mentioned, the regular consumption of anabolic steroids is an important cause of male infertility, due to the hampered action of testosterone in the testes (1, 7).
Modern lifestyle has been shown to play an important role in fertility. Attempting pregnancy before the age of 30-35 may provide the highest probabilities of success for women. Considering social, professional and personal reasons, it is then advisable to take into account the current possibilities available for fertility preservation while still possible (1).
Because of the impact of nutrition and physical activity on fertility, controlling and maintaining healthy dietary habits (as well as a healthy weight) may provide a way for couples to increase their chances to conceive (1).
As long as there is no pathological cause for infertility, the solution to some related problems may be as simple as to correct certain wrong habits (8). By understanding the impact of lifestyle on reproductive health and by actively modifying specific behaviour patterns, men and women may be capable of controlling their own fertility potential (1).
http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/topics/infertility/definitions/en/ (september 5, 2017)
http://www.minifiv.es/2017/02/como-afecta-el-estilo-de-vida-a-la-fertilidad/ (september 20, 2017)
Author: Belén Gómez Giménez
It is well known that women age is important for reproduction. The female biological clock is well-defined temporally and biologically, with declining oocyte production when the woman is in her late 30s or early 40s and cessation of menses in the late 40s and early 50s. Whereas woman’s chances to conceive naturally drop sharply, male fertility does not cease abruptly, since androgen production and spermatogenesis continue throughout life. There are some worldwide-known examples of famous personalities who fathered children at an advanced age, like Julio Iglesias´s senior (90), Luciano Pavarotti (68) or Rod Stewart (66).
A great problem in our society and that of industrialized countries is that couples wait longer to have children, and advances in reproductive technology currently allow older men and women to consider being parents. However, many studies highlight age as an important factor to conceive in both sexes. During years, fertility research has focused mainly on women age, and so potential adverse effects of male age might have passed unnoticed. However, there is currently a great concern about the decreasing quality of sperm with age in men. In 2010, the World Health OrganiSation (WHO) changed criteria to semen evaluation, due to a decreased concentration and normal sperm morphology below the threshold for which a semen sample was considered of good quality.
On the other hand, some research lines show that in men, advanced age affects sperm quality (decreases semen volume and reduces the percentage of normal sperm morphology and motility). It also affects non-reproductive physiological issues such as libido or erectile function. Blood testosterone levels decline with age in most men, even in healthy ones; this decline probably begins around the age of thirty, which has been termed andropause. So, similarly to women, aging in men is also associated to a drop in sex hormone levels; therefore, we can talk about an effective male biological clock. These changes in sex hormone levels and sperm quality could affect fertility, because sperm genetic material is altered and, as a consequence, the risk of spontaneous abortion is increased due to offspring genetic abnormalities.
IS AGE IN MEN ASSOCIATED WITH DIFFERENT OFFSPRING DISEASES OR LIVE BIRTH RATES?
These alterations could explain the association of paternal age with the increased incidence of some psychiatric disorders such as those of the autism spectrum, psychosis, schizophrenia and bipolar disorders at childbearing. Moreover, there seems to be supporting evidence that paternal age significantly influences the incidence of having a child with Down syndrome when combined with maternal age. This could also be the case for other genetic abnormalities, which could in turn lead to miscarriage or different diseases in the newborns.
Finally, It has been demonstrated that men over 35 years old are twice as likely to be infertile (defined as the inability to achieve a pregnancy within 12 months).
A recent study reported at European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology congress in July 2017 found that couples with both members under 30 had around 70% chance of having a live birth after an in vitro fertilization cycle. However, that success rate fell to around 50% when the man was aged 40-42.
In summary, age is an important factor both in women and in men, but It should also be taken into consideration that there are other factors such as obesity, habitual alcohol and/or tobacco intake and stress, among other well-studied elements, which might be effectively altering our fertility potential.
Currently available data not only show that male biological clock does exist, but it is also important to fertility. Mechanisms of action are unclear, but as above-exposed, they might involve impaired semen parameters and increased levels of damaged sperm DNA, which could affect fertilization, implantation and even embryo development.
1- D'Onofrio BM, Rickert ME, Frans E, Kuja-Halkola R, Almqvist C, Sjölander A, et al. Paternal age at childbearing and offspring psychiatric and academic morbidity. JAMA Psychiatry. 2014;71(4):432-8.
2- Dodge L, Penzias A, Hacker M. The impact of male partner age on cumulative incidence of live birth following in vitro fertilization. Oral communication at the ESHRE. 2017.
3- Eskenazi B, Wyrobek AJ, Sloter E, Kidd SA, Moore L, Young S, et al. The association of age and semen quality in healthy men. Hum Reprod. 2003;18(2):447-54.
4- Fisch, H. The male biological clock. In: D. Carrell, ed. Paternal Influences on Human Reproductive Success. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2013. pp.61-69.
5- Fisch, H, Braun S. In: Simon and Schuster, ed. The male biological clock. The startling news about aging, sexuality, and fertility in man. New York: Free press, 2005. p.10.
6- Fisch H, Hyun G, Golden R, Hensle TW, Olsson CA, Liberson GL. The influence of paternal age on down syndrome. J Urol. 2003;169(6):2275-8.
7- Harris ID, Fronczak C, Roth L, Meacham RB. Fertility and the aging male. Rev Urol. 2011;13(4):e184-90.
8- Pasqualotto FF, Borges Júnior E, Pasqualotto EB. The male biological clock is ticking: a review of the literature. Sao Paulo Med J. 2008;126(3):197-201.
9- WHO laboratory manual for the examination and processing of human semen- 5th ed. In: Geneva: WHO Press, 2010.
10- WHO laboratory manual for the examination of human semen and sperm-cervical mucus interaction- 4th ed. In: Cambrige University Press, 1999.
Author: Shuyana Deba
In today's society, egg freezing has become a trending issue, normally associated with those women who want to delay their maternity. But, what does egg freezing really mean? Let’s try to explain this item clearly from the point of view of the assisted reproduction laboratory.
Oocyte cryopreservation is the term used for what is socially known as "egg freezing". Cryopreservation is an option for those who want to preserve their fertility. This process refers to the use of ultra low temperatures to preserve gametes (oocytes from women and spermatozoa from men). It can also be used to preserve embryos or even reproductive tissues (like ovarian or testicular tissue) down to subzero temperatures in order to stop all biological activity, maintaining the appropriate conditions for future use. This has been proofed of particular help in cases in which the individual had to be treated with aggressive therapies, like those required to fight cancer. In such cases, normally partial extraction of the gonadal tissue (ovary or testis) is followed by cryopreservation until the patient overcomes the clinical situation and is ready to conceive. After extensive research, most assisted reproduction laboratories currently use vitrification, an ultra rapid freezing technology (-196˚C with liquid nitrogen) that avoids the formation of damaging ice crystals in the cells while ensuring their viability after thawing for future fertilization.
INDICATIONS FOR OOCYTE CRYOPRESERVATION
This technique was initially reserved for those women with specific medical indications who had no other fertility options. Progress made in the field of cancer treatments has contributed to the increase of cancer survival rates in populations. However, these treatments are known to affect negatively the fertility potential. In those cases, oocyte cryopreservation can provide hope for fertility preservation.
Egg freezing is also indicated for cases of premature menopause and, consequently, the loss of ovarian function at an early age. However, it must be considered that some cases of early loss of ovarian function might be due to genetic causes, which may be eventually transmitted to the next generation. That is why every single case must be addressed individually and independently subjected to counselling. This would allow to evaluate whether cryopreservation of oocytes and delayed motherhood is actually a good option.
Nowadays, another application for oocyte vitrification is the creation of donor oocyte banks for egg donation programs. One of the great advantages of this is that menstrual synchronization between donor and recipient is not required. Moreover, leftover oocytes are stored for another cycle.
Furthermore, oocyte cryopreservation is useful in those cases in which the woman has been subjected to ovarian stimulation, and yet the male partner fails to produce a semen sample on the day of oocyte recovery. Additionally, it has also been proposed as an efficient strategy for women who had a low response to the stimulation treatments, so the oocyte number recovered in a cycle is not high enough. Thanks to vitrification, those women can store and accumulate oocytes from multiple ovarian stimulation cycles.
However, as it has been mentioned above, the egg freezing approach is currently catching more attention from society due to the increasing number of women who want to delay their motherhood. This means they would be attempting to preserve fertility ahead of any age-related issue that could decrease it. The reason is that fecundity in women is gradually reduced, but there is a significant decline around age 32, and even more pronounced from 37 onwards. This scientific fact is explained by the natural reduction of the oocyte number in the ovaries (ovarian reserve), which happens naturally and progressively in every healthy woman. So, age at the time of oocyte cryopreservation is crucial for the outcome of the technique.
It is also worth to take into consideration the number of embryos generated during cycles. Since implantation rates have improved considerably and the risks of multiple pregnancy are high, there is a tendency to perform single embryo transfer, when possible. Due to the controversy around the definition of an embryo (meaning legal definition that refers to legal rights of the unborn), cryopreservation of supernumerary embryos have raised ethical and legal concerns in many countries. As a consequence, it is not uncommon to see differences in legislation on these matters between countries. With this regard, cryopreservation of oocytes can bypass such problems, given the fact that an oocyte is by no means an individual or human being when it comes to legal issues.
FACTORS AFFECTING OOCYTE SURVIVAL
The main difficulty the oocyte faces for cryopreservation is its own shape and volume. In particular, the oocyte membrane gets frequently damaged and ruptured, which could lead to immediate death of the cell. Since the oocyte is a single cell structure, there is no backup for recovery from serious injuries, as opposed to multicellular embryos.
Additionally, women age at the moment of egg freezing is a critical factor, not only because the oocyte number decreases over time, but also because their quality is reduced, as well. In fact, several clinical studies have shown that oocyte survival after cryopreservation is higher in younger women (<35 years old) than in +36-year old women.
RESULTS OBTAINED USING VITRIFIED OOCYTES
Several studies have demonstrated that there has been no increase in the number of anomalies in children born from oocytes fertilized after freezing and thawing. Nevertheless, the live birth rate per patient was statistically higher in younger patients compared to older ones (50% vs. 22.9%), regarding age at egg vitrification. Additionally, when older women go back to their vitrified oocytes, they are also more likely to experience pregnancy complications.
It is important to highlight that society is not yet aware of the importance of age for oocyte vitrification. As a consequence, and even though elective freezing of oocytes for delaying childbearing is becoming one of the most frequent indications for fertility preservation, it is still a decision made at a late stage, after which results may not be as good as expected.
It seems that there is not enough information for women on risks, potential, resources and outcomes. Given the tendency of today’s society to postpone the moment of childbearing, women should be aware of all possibilities and difficulties, the earlier the better. If science and media manage to spread that information so that it reaches young women at the right time, decision-making would be improved and women considering going for oocyte cryopreservation would be able to make up their mind on time before it is too late.
2016-2018. All Rights Reserved by Embryologist Media.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.